Depth Chart 1.0: How CPL Editorial sees CanMNT squad options entering 2019

It’s a massive year for Canada’s men’s national team.

Coach John Herdman will guide his team through the final stages of CONCACAF Nations League Qualifying, before likely turning an eye to the 2019 Gold Cup in June. With the Nations League getting into full swing this year, too, Canadian fans have plenty of meaningful matches to look forward to in 2019.

With that in mind, the players making up the national team will have an abundance of opportunities to impress, such that the team’s lineup might just change come June 15, when the Gold Cup begins.

Who does Herdman have on offer from his player pool? Here’s how CPL Editorial sees Canada’s depth options across the field, keeping in mind that many of these players can and have played in multiple positions for both club and country:


Milan 2
Milan Borjan of Red Star Belgrade enjoyed a stellar Champions League campaign in 2018 (Canada Soccer).
  1. Milan Borjan (Red Star Belgrade)
  2. Maxime Crepeau (Whitecaps FC)
  3. Simon Thomas (Strommen IF)

On the cusp: Alessandro Busti (Juventus), James Pantemis (Montreal Impact), Jayson Leutwiler (Blackburn Rovers), Marco Carducci (Cavalry FC), Tyson Farago (Valour FC)

Red Star Belgrade shot-stopper Milan Borjan is the clear No. 1 for 2019, and probably beyond as the veteran Canadian has been lights-out for his club in UEFA Champions League play, stifling tough competition.

Crepeau could see plenty of minutes with the Whitecaps this season, while Simon Thomas just edges out Juventus’ Alessandro Busti for the third spot, though Herdman is for want of little when it comes to his goalkeeping options.

Right Fullback

  1. Michael Petrasso (Montreal Impact)
  2. Zachary Brault-Guillard (Lyon II)
  3. Marcus Godinho (Heart of Midlothian)

On the cusp: Fraser Aird (Dundee United), Chris Serban (Cavalry FC), Juan Cordova (Huachipato)

Montreal’s Michael Petrasso is probably the first-choice option at right fullback, having earned a spot in the 2017 Gold Cup roster, but with Zachary Brault-Guillard coming up through the ranks both for club and country, this spot could be contested in 2019. Marcus Godinho is another option to watch, while Fraser Aird of Dundee is another regular inclusion of late.


  1. Derek Cornelius (FK Javor Ivanjica)
  2. Doneil Henry (Whitecaps FC)
  3. Adam Straith (VfL Sportfreunde Lotte)
  1. Manjrekar James (FC Midtjylland)
  2. David Edgar (Unattached)
  3. Steven Vitoria (Lechia Gdansk)

On the cusp: Skylar Thomas (Valour FC), Dejan Jakovic (Los Angeles FC), Andre Hainault (1. FC Kaiserslautern)

Canadian young player of the year Derek Cornelius earns the nod ahead of Doneil Henry while Manjrekar James keeps his place, though you’d have to imagine that David Edgar could challenge either for a starting role in 2019. Could Valour FC’s Skylar Thomas do the same with consistent showings in CPL action?

Adam Straith, Steven Vitoria and potentially Andre Hainault and Dejan Jakovic are currently in reserve.

Left Fullback

  1. Marcel de Jong (Whitecaps FC)
  2. Sam Adekugbe (Valerenga)
  3. Raheem Edwards (Chicago Fire)

On the cusp: Ashtone Morgan (Toronto FC), Ryan Telfer (Toronto FC)

We don’t believe Alphonso Davies is a left fullback, and against tougher CONCACAF opposition, his attacking prowess could be wasted if Les Rouges are pinned back. It’s why Marcel de Jong is our preferred starter, bringing a touch of experience to an otherwise young backline. In the future? It’s Sam Adekugbe’s spot to lose, though Raheem Edwards could challenge with solid showings in Chicago.

Keep an eye on Toronto FC’s Ryan Telfer as another longterm option, too, with a few names currently signed to CPL deals potentially in the hunt.

Defensive Midfielder

Atiba Hutchinson has amassed 80 caps for Canada since 2003 (Canada Soccer).
  1. Atiba Hutchinson (Besiktas)
  2. Samuel Piette (Montreal Impact)
  3. Mark-Anthony Kaye (Los Angeles FC)

On the cusp: Will Johnson (Orlando City), Liam Fraser (Toronto FC), Nik Ledgerwood (Cavalry FC)

Atiba Hutchinson, the man known affectionately as “The Octopus,” starts deep in the Canadian midfield, his best position for club and country. Behind him? Samuel Piette, the obvious understudy, but keep an eye on Los Angeles FC’s Mark-Anthony Kaye – the surprise starter turned heads in 2018 before picking up an ill-timed injury and could return to action on the same pace needed to earn consideration at the international level.

Other options include Will Johnson and Liam Fraser, though the former hasn’t been in the fold of late, while the versatile Ledgerwood would fit into his natural position here, too. Could FC Edmonton’s Allan Zebie also earn a call-up?

Central Midfielder

  1. Scott Arfield (Rangers)
  2. Jay Chapman (Toronto FC)
  3. David Wotherspoon (St. Johnstone)

On the cusp: Daniel Stanese (Energie Cottbus), Pedro Pacheco (Santa Clara)

Captain Scott Arfield is an assured starter in the Canadian midfield, deputized by Toronto FC’s Jay Chapman, but beyond that, the third option is wide open. There are some Canadian talents abroad who have been used in the past, but this is one position that Herdman isn’t exactly hard-pressed to decide over. The more likely case is that Russell Teibert or Samuel Piette figure into this secondary midfield role depending on need and availability.

Attacking Midfielder

  1. Jonathan Osorio (Toronto FC)
  2. Russell Teibert (Whitecaps FC)
  3. Kyle Bekker (Forge FC)

On the cusp: Sergio Camargo (Cavalry FC), Kianz Froese (Fortuna Dusseldorf)

Jonathan Osorio had too good a season with Toronto FC last year not to be considered a starter for Canada in 2019: 17 goals in 43 games across all competitions spells the story of a breakout year for the Brampton, Ont. man. He’ll be deputized by Teibert, who can fit into a variety of roles as needed. But keep an eye on Kyle Bekker, too. The Forge FC signing had a stellar 2018 season with North Carolina FC last year, recording 13 assists. He could figure his way back in with equal levels of production in 2019.

Right Winger

Alphonso Davies (Canada Soccer)
Alphonso Davies recently completed a $22M move to Bayern Munich (Canada Soccer).
  1. Alphonso Davies (Bayern Munich)
  2. Ballou Tabla (FC Barcelona B)
  3. Liam Millar (Liverpool FC)

On the cusp: Chris Nanco (Forge FC), Kyle Porter (York9 FC)

Simply put, we don’t believe Davies should be used as a left fullback, and instead, should play much higher up as an attacking option for Herdman’s side. In a position manned by young, talented players, Davies is the obvious standout, having been named Canadian Player of the Year for 2018 as he headed off to Bayern Munich.

Barcelona B attacker Ballou Tabla is another fine choice, as is versatile attack-minded winger Liam Millar over at Liverpool’s youth ranks. Both players offer Herdman plenty of energy and skill, and can be used in many different positions, as needed.

Centre Forward

  1. Lucas Cavallini (Puebla)
  2. Cyle Larin (Besiktas)
  3. Tosaint Ricketts (Unattached)

On the cusp: Marcus Haber (Pacific FC), Anthony Jackson-Hamel (Montreal Impact), Jordan Hamilton (Toronto FC)

Lucas Cavallini is in better form than Cyle Larin at the moment, which is why he’s our preferred starter in this attack-minded formation. While Larin could provide Herdman with more of a poacher’s instinct, the dynamism of Canada’s attacking front plays more in Cavallini’s favour, as his hold-up play and movement is more in-tune with that of his teammates’. Ricketts sits third in line, for now.

After that? Marcus Haber, Anthony Jackson-Hamel and Jordan Hamilton each offer their own take on the centre forward role, with Haber preferred due to his size and experience abroad.

Left Winger

  1. Junior Hoilett (Cardiff City)
  2. Jonathan David (KAA Gent)
  3. Randy Edwini-Bonsu (FC Edmonton)

On the cusp: Tesho Akindele (Orlando City), Kris Twardek (Sligo Rovers)

You’ve got to wonder if Herdman has ever considered a six-man frontline consisting of Junior Hoilett, Jonathan David, Cavallini, Davies, Tabla and Osorio, such is the breadth of options Canada seems to have found in the last two years. Hoilett is, of course, the starter out wide, challenged by the versatile Jonathan David, who can play up top as well, if required.

Randy Edwini-Bonsu is another versatile attacker who could figure into this spot, combining speed and a goal-scorer’s threat with renewed purpose, as FC Edmonton provides him with the sort of meaningful minutes needed to regain his top form.

Here’s what CPL Editorial’s 1st depth chart of 2019 looks like:

CPL Editorials’ 1st depth chart of 2019 for the Canadian men’s national team.